cellphone vs radioWe often are asked by friends, family and clients about the status of 2-way radio in a world where everyone seems to be carrying their own personal communications device, a cell phone. Here are some of our thoughts and thoughts of those in this industry concerning this subject.

Most people would admit they could not function without their smart phone, the computer attached to your hip. But in reality, as a communications device, a cell phone is still a device for making a phone call to another person. You dial a number, let it ring, wait for an answer, hope to talk to the person you are calling, possibly leaving a voice message. The process takes at least a minute of your time or more just to connect. And following this routine, you may end up having a conversation for several minutes.

When using a two-way radio you simply press the push-to-talk (PTT) button and instantly speak to your group (or one-to-one depending on your radio system). You can give a brief message or instruction, receive an immediate response and finish your task accordingly. The entire process typically takes a few seconds. It is fast and efficient, saving time and money. In the realm of public safety and businesses such as construction, it can save lives. In addition, radios are highly effective in high noise environments, built rugged for long-term use, offer an intuitive one-touch user interface, and feature a battery designed to do a full day’s work.

Nearly all business models of two-way radios are repairable and have replacement battery packs available. The life expectancy of a two-way radios is up to 10 years, with many exceeding this mark.  Computing the cost of purchasing a typical business 2-way radio (Motorola CP200) over 10 years including replacement batteries every two years and 1-2 repairs, it would calculate to under $10/month to own/operate the radio. Much less than the overall cost of cellular for the same time period.

Cellular devices are generally speaking rather fragile. The majority are too lightweight for work environments. Battery packs are often non-replaceable.  If you talk to those in the cellular industry, you will find the life expectancy of a phone is about two years. At the 2-year mark, the cell carriers are ready to make a deal with you where you can get the next model “free” or inexpensively to keep you as a client. The industry is reliant upon the monthly fees we all pay. We’ll let you do the math on what a maintaining a cell phone will cost you over the course of 10 years.

Radio communication is instantaneous with the simple use of a PTT button. The person needing information  receives it quickly. Requests for assistance are heard by everyone monitoring the frequency. This is essential in many industries and especially in public safety. Radios designed for public safety can also have other features such as an emergency button or a mandown feature where the radio will notify dispatch of an officer who is no longer vertical. In construction when giving instructions to a crane operator PTT radio technology is the quickest form of communication.  Think about restaurant hostesses or retail clerks communicating with others on their team. This type of communication is done more efficiently using a radio versus a cell phone. It would be hard to imagine the public safety or business world without 2-way radios.

Cellphone & CP200 side-by-sideAnd up to now we haven’t mentioned the downside of using a cellular device instead of a radio, things such as surfing the web, playing games, making personal calls, just aren’t a problem when businesses use two-way radios for their onsite communications. So when choosing between using your smart phone and 2-way radios, you can see where the two devices differ both in features and overall long term cost. Both have their place where they can work to the best advantage. It’s up to you as a business person to choose your communications device wisely. ~cl


Two-way radios remain the most reliable and economic way for those in business and public safety to communicate.  Pressing the push-to-talk button is instantaneous communication with one or many. Unlike cellular service which is often spotty, service outages, or dropped calls, the simple two-way radio is consistent and is there when you need to communicate.

A two-way business radio’s life expectancy is typically last 5-15 years. Radios can take the punishment of a 40-hour work week. Unlike cellphones which have a short 2 year life expectancy, and lack durability. Specifically when comparing a two-way radio being used in a business and a cellphone. Radios will tolerate more dust, dirt, humidity, moisture, and vibration. Business and commercial radios are expected to work in the rough and tumble world of business and public safety.

Repairability: Nearly all models of two-way Motorola radios are repairable, and have replacement rechargeable battery packs available. This can keep the radio functioning well into the future. We often see well loved radios here at the repair center, in for a tune up, when they are 15-20 years old. Could you imagine still having your smartphone in 15-20 years. The iPhone was not designed to have a replaceable battery pack, however, if you know a very tech savvy person, you might get it accomplished.

When you have employees using cellphones, you create an environment for them to make personal calls, play games, surf the internet. If the same employee is using a two-way radio, you greatly reduce the likelihood of these undesired communications. The two-way radio and the cellphone both have their place in communication. Radios = serious business, cellphones = personal communication/internet/entertainment. Both have their place where they can shine and work for the benefit of the user.

More later…


5 Jan, 2012

RADIOS: Motorola Solutions (the two-way radio company) has established a take-back recycling program to responsibly dispose of used Motorola radio equipment. We participate in this program.  If you do not have a recycling option in your community you can send the radios and/or batteries to our radio repair facility and we will take care of the disposal for you. FYI: Clearly mark it is “FOR RECYCLING”. Otherwise, it might end up in line for radio repair. ☺

CELLPHONES: Motorola Mobility (the cellphone company) offers recycling for old Motorola phones. You can get a free postage paid label at this link.

BATTERIES: RBRC accepts rechargeable radio/cellphone batteries for recycling, check for a RBRC drop-off in your area. Visit their website to find a location near you www.call2recycle.org.

Happy New Year! ~cl

Non-radio users often ask why would someone use a radio instead of a cellphone. Here a few answers:

1) When you need immediate ability to communicate on-site to one or many at the press of a button. Radios are the most reliable method.

2) No monthly bill. No minutes.

3) Durability. Business radios are designed to go a 40-hour work week. Many are rated for resistance to moisture, dust, and humidity. They are made to be a workhorse.

4) Using handheld radios for on-site communications can keep workers on task, and prevent the abuses seen with cellphones. (No calling home or surfing the web on a 2-way radio.)

5) Longer life expectancy. Most cellphones last 2-3 years at best. Business two-way radios typically last 5-7 years, or even longer if you have them serviced as needed.

6) Business radios are typically repairable at a reasonable rate, while cellphones usually require replacement.

Just a few thoughts to ponder. You may be able to add more…

There are situations where cellphones are ideal. But in the situation of public safety, business or on-site communications, radios still give you the best all around solution.


%d bloggers like this: